Report on the Returning of Displaced People

From the Three Refugee Camps

First Quarter 1999

Introduction

After the 5-6 July 1997 event, there many Cambodian people went to Thailand to take refuge, creating three refuge camps as follows:

1. Huy Cheuon in Sorin province with 6,888 refugees;
2.Phu Noy in Sisaket province with 15,261 refugees;
3.Chong Kov Plu in Trat province (Thailand) adjacent to Samlot district, Battambang province (Cambodia). 14,791 displaced people are registered in this camp.

In October 1997 the Cambodian Red Cross (CRC) signed an agreement with UNHCR for the returning of the refugee people from the above mentioned camps. At the first step, CRC began to deal with the return of refugees from Huy Cheoun camp through Poy Pet to the Kang Va camp based in Sisophon, Banteay Meanchey province. These returnees then were allowed to go back to the province of their origin at choice. After the election, the improved political situation in Cambodia constituted the increase in the number of refugees willing to come back to their homeland, which made CRC difficult to cope with the transportation of the increased number of refugees. As a matter of fact, since Jan 5 the returning operation has been organized in a larger scale for several times with a short period to be prepared for. As a result, the previous planned operations had to be revised accordingly.

By the end of 1998, with the formation of the new coalition government, the political situation is improved, and the Royal Government issued the letter 10 dated 4 Jan 1999 instructing CRC to take fall responsibility for the return of the refugees.

CRC began negotiations with HCR to design strategy for the quick return of refugees, based on the principles of safety, dignity, and free choice for final destination.

II- Strategy for the Return of Refugees, Refugee Statistics

1- Via Poy Pet

The transportation of refugees from the HRC camp was organized by Thai counterpart with private buses until Poy Pet, where the refugees were transferred to the CRC trucks to be transported to Kang Va camp in Sosophon. After staying for 2 days, the refugees were sent to the homeland either by the CRC trucks or private cars depending on the number of refugees going to each destination.

a) Refugee Statistics

1997: between 10/97 and 12/97

Date of return

Stage

Total Number of refugees

Number of refugees by age

Family

People

more then 13 years

6-12 years

less then 5 years

Total Female Total Female Total Female Total Female
10/10/97 1 59 244 124 185 90 31 18 28 16
13/10/97 2 79 233 98 181 71 25 12 27 15
16/10/97 3 81 222 101 169 74 19 12 34 15
21/10/97 4 90 309 137 237 100 25 14 47 23
24/10/97 5 104 346 170 242 111 48 30 56 29
27/10/97 6 147 448 186 322 131 62 31 64 24
4/11/97 7 149 449 199 315 138 56 27 78 34
7/11/97 8 164 485 202 328 130 80 35 77 37
18/11/97 9 105 269 117 191 84 44 24 34 9
21/11/97 10 54 121 54 83 33 25 15 13 6
25/11/97 11 22 48 26 35 19 7 5 6 2
17/12/97 12 63 137 60 95 40 18 10 24 10

1997 TOTAL

1117 3311 1474 2383 1021 440 233 488 220

1998: between 01/98 and 12/98

Date of return

Stage

Total Number of refugees

Number of refugees by age

Family

People

more then 13 years

6-12 years

less then 5 years

Total Female Total Female Total Female Total Female
6/1/98 1 61 123 58 94 45 14 9 15 4
3/2/98 2 48 104 36 81 26 13 8 10 2
24/2/98 3 32 57 25 46 21 3 1 8 3
5/5/98 4 71 140 59 107 45 14 7 19 7
14/5/98 5 44 196 112 105 64 48 22 43 26
19/5/98 6 117 279 131 196 91 41 16 42 24
28/5/98 7 30 121 67 70 40 25 13 26 14
2/6/98 8 81 191 75 144 49 23 13 24 13
16/6/98 9 53 176 92 107 60 42 23 27 9
23/6/98 10 124 223 82 172 53 20 12 31 17
26/6/98 11 95 396 195 240 122 70 30 86 43
10/7/98 12 44 181 95 101 55 35 12 45 28
13/7/98 13 136 253 111 175 68 38 20 40 23
18/7/98 14 165 641 323 358 189 163 81 120 53
4/8/98 15 197 755 418 412 246 179 94 164 78
10/8/98 16 69 127 62 91 41 21 11 15 10
25/8/98 17 84 289 145 160 86 66 30 63 29
2/9/98 18 242 551 275 365 180 91 47 95 48
15/9/98 19 18 63 36 35 19 14 6 14 11
6/10/98 20 282 443 178 321 128 62 25 60 25
10/11/98 21 122 293 151 198 93 43 26 52 32
9/12/98 22 10 41 20 20 12 15 6 6 2
22/12/98 23 222 609 318 356 201 120 60 133 57
29/12/98 24 239 669 379 396 224 151 86 122 69

1998 TOTAL

2596 6921 3443 4350 2158 1311 658 1260 627

1999: between 01/99 and 03/99

Date of return

Stage

Total Number of refugees

Number of refugees by age

Family

People

more then 13 years

6-12 years

less then 5 years

Total Female Total Female Total Female Total Female
5/1/99 1 146 352 182 223 121 60 27 69 34
12/1/99 2 77 395 204 187 105 105 53 103 46
15/1/99 3 116 610 313 305 167 176 87 129 59
20/1/99 4 93 405 224 236 134 110 63 59 27
22/1/99 5 122 699 384 328 188 217 118 154 78
26/1/99 6 158 835 445 436 236 254 117 145 90
29/l/99 7 184 836 411 424 227 260 116 152 68
2/2/99 8 203 605 294 368 176 154 82 83 36
9/2/99 9 88 204 100 140 66 30 18 34 16
16/2/99 10 289 859 424 514 269 189 87 156 68
23/2/99 11 284 868 435 483 260 189 82 196 93
1/3/99 12 164 438 225 266 139 72 33 100 53
9/3/99 13 301 721 322 506 214 82 36 133 72
16/3/99 14 288 818 445 457 263 191 94 170 88
24/3/99 15 299 707 364 443 239 150 69 114 56
1999 TOTAL 2812 9352 4772 5316 2806 2239 1082 1797 884
GRAND TOTAL 6525 19584 9689 12049 5985 3990 1973 3545 1731

b) Strategy

- From Poy Pet to Kang Va: trucks were divided into two types, one for carrying luggage and materials, and another for people.

- 2 days of stay in Kang Va:

- From Kang Va to final destination: CRC provided trucks if the number of refugees to a destination is more than 40, and if the number is small they received the amount of money for taxi instead. At the same time on Feb 12 there was the arrival of returnees from Samlot. CRC also organized transportation of food to Anlong Veng.

c) Special conditions between Jan and March 1999

Based on the above statistics we observed the increase in the number of refugees in Kang Va camp in a frequent arrival for every week, and the final destination is much farther. In this case, CRC decided to change the strategy as the following:

- the delay of staying for one week or up to 10 days, in order to gather more people

- effective movement of trucks for timely transportation of refugees

2. Via Samlot from Chong Kov Plu

The previous request of CRC was stated that the return of refugees had to be organized through Poy Pet, given the better condition for CRC operation. However since January the situation has changed all for the better, and CRC agreed with HCR to open another access point in Samlot.

a) Preparation

Between Jan 8 and Feb 5 there were subsequent meetings among HCR, CMAC, CRC, Military Officers, and provincial, district authorities to discuss several issues as below:

1. Road safety: mines, demining, and responsibility

2. How to transport the refugees from HCR, role of CRC;

3. Where to organize distribution of kits, food;

4. Road and bridges reconstruction and construction of temporally camp (local authority is in charge)

b) Operation

Following 6 meetings, particularly between CRC and HCR, decisions were made as the following:

- A location near the bridge O Ta Teak was chosen for CRC headquarter situated about 16 kin from the refugee camp and 20 km from Ta Sanh, district center of Samlot;

- The distribution of kits and food is committed by CRC and WFP;

- The refugees travel from the camp to receive food and kits and continue to travel to the final destination by their own;

- Specify the schedule of returning

c) Note

1. Between 0 Ta Teak and Bridge Dong Tong, where CRC trucks are carrying foods and materials for the refugees, CRC is willing to help those families who travel in this road section;

2. Of the refugees via Samlot 521 families with 2048 person went to Veal Veng to settle in 5 commune in Pur Sat province;

3. A lot of refugees would like to return to 7 commune in Samlot district, where some villages have poor road access, uncertainty of mines because of being long abandoned, for example village Chamlong Kouy, Lpeou etc.

d) Statistics and Schedule

Date #Trip

# Manifest

# Distributed

Not at distribution

Remarks

#Families #People #Families #People #Families #People
12/2/99

D1

195 680 195 678     TO: 4p
13/2/99 D2 197 635 197 628     TO: 7p
Total 392 1315 392 1306      
15/2/99 D3 195 580 195 576     TO: 4p
18/2/99 D4 198 627 198 623     TO: 4p
19/2/99 D5 199 667 198 663 1 4  
Total 592 1874 591 1862      
23/2/99 D6 193 581 193 581      
24/2/99 D7 245 245 244 760 1 4 (+1F=1P new Manifest)
25/2/99 D8 247 845 247 845      
26/2/99 D9 245 907 245 907      
27/2/99 D10 250 820 250 820      
Total D10 1180 3398 1179 3913      
Sub-total 1OD 2164 6587 2162 7081 2 8 TO : 19p
2/3/99 D11 250 853 250 853      
3/3/99 D12 251 858 251 858      
4/3/99 D13 246 916 246 916      
5/3/99 D14 246 933 246 933      
6/3/99 D15 240 814 240 814      
Total 1233 4374 1233 4374      
9/2/99 D16 243 950 243 950      
10/3/99 D17 246 984 245 981 1 3  
11/3/99 D18 255 1044 255 1044      
12/4/99 D19 299 1046 299 1046      
Total 1043 4024 1042 4021 1 3  
Sub-total 2276 8398 2275 8395      

Grand Total 4440 14985
Distributed: 4437 15476
Absentee 3 11
TO:   19
(in manifest)
(TO: 2p)

e) Veal Veng, Pur Sat

The district has the same mine and access problem as in Samlot, and contains 5 communes under administration:

Pra Moy 184 families = 890 person
Kra Peu Pi 81 families = 447 person
Thmar Da 34 families= 172 person
Anlong Reap 249 families = 1068 person
0 Saom 225 families = 985 person

Most of the 2048 returnees from Samlot would like to live in Pra Moy and Kra Peu Pi communes. These people received food for about 50 days and would face the food shortage in the rainy season, because they have little capability to clear forest for fice field. WFP has a plan to provide food assistance to these people, but do not yet decide. CRC had requested WFP to decide as quickly as possible, in order for timely distribution before the rain starts.

3. Via AnIong Veng

The refugees left the camp in Sisaket by their own for Cambodia to settle in 2 districts, namely Anlong Veng and Tra Peang Prasat.

a) Geography and Statistics

1) Anlong Veng has 5 communes

No Commune Village Resident Returnees Total Remarks
Fam people Farn People Fam People
1 Anlong Veng 10 1319 7457 633 2255 1952 9712  
2 Thlat 7 598 3104 259 1153 857 4257  
3 Lom Tong 5 195 1230 397 1636 592 2866  
4 Tra Paing Prey 7 338 2049 1095 4444 1433 6493  
5 Tra Paing Tro 2 163 1041 39 145 202 1186  
Total 5 communes 31 2613 14881 2423 9633 5036 24514  

The district has one district hospital supported by Medicine San Frontier (MSF) and primary school. Pure water supply is critical during the dry season, only one pond is available. The roads from district to communes are not good but clear of mines.

2) Tra Peang Prasat has 6 communes

No Commune Village Resident Returnees Total Remarks
Fam people Farn People Fam People
1 Trapaing Prasat 8 504 2883 220 1114 784 3997  
2 Tum Nop Dach 6 307 1625 5 29 312 1654  
3 Preas Pralay 5 200 1080 9 42 209 1122  
4 O Svay 5 191 1134 11 55 202 1189  
5 Bak An Lung 5 204 937 6 17 210 954  
6 Pha Av 8 242 1342 308 1887 550 3229  
Total

There is no school no hospital, and the district building is just being constructed. The water supply is worse than in Anlong Veng, and the roads are very bad and difficult to travel during the wet season.

b) Population and livelihood

Most of the refugees are ethnic minority coming from Mondol Kiri, Ratanak Kiri, Stoeng Treng, Kratie. They returned from Phu Noy camp via Poy Pet, and through Kang Va camp, which destined to 4 provinces:

- Mondol Kiri :308 families = 1571 person
- Rattanak Kiri :197 families = 1065 person
- Kratie :173 families = 888 person
- Stoeng Treng :51 fan-Alies = 257 person

These people left their homeland for 20 years with a military or farmer background. The distance to Siem Reap is more than 100 km and is accessible by car only during the dry season, while by ox car during the wet season. The people from these two districts immigrate to two camps- Phu Noy and 0 Bay Tab of Sre Noy commune, but are together when return home.

III- Conclusion

4 districts are the final destination for the refugees, namely Samlot (Battambang), Veal Veng (Pur Sat), Anlong Veng and Trapeang Prasat (Siem Reap). Roads are accessible during the dry season for small and big vehicles, such as Land cruiser with 4 wheel driver. So infrastructure rehabilitation should be planned for a certain period, which enable the transportation, travel, and economic development of the region.